November 20, 2026
Insurance

Brinks beats “secret insurance” claim in jewelry transport fight


The defense was creative: call the transport contract illegal insurance. It didn’t work

Brinks beats “secret insurance” claim in jewelry transport fight

What happened: A New York appeals court ruled that Brinks’ valuables transport contract is not an insurance policy, defeating a defendant’s unlicensed-insurer defense 

Who’s involved: Brinks Global Services USA and D’Amati LLC 

What’s at stake: Whether transport contracts that promise to cover lost goods amount to illegal insurance 

Why it matters: The ruling draws a firm line between transport liability and insurance – relevant to any carrier or broker handling high-value goods 

Where it stands: Affirmed by the Appellate Division, First Department, on November 19, 2026 

Brinks promised to pay for jewelry lost in its care – so a defendant argued the transport giant was secretly selling insurance without a license. 

A New York appeals court was not persuaded. 

The Appellate Division, First Department, affirmed a lower court ruling that Brinks’ “Valuables Transport Contract” is exactly what it sounds like – a transport contract, not an insurance policy. The decision killed a defense that, if successful, would have doomed Brinks’ lawsuit entirely. 

The dispute involved Brinks’ “Door to Door” service for shipping valuables. Under the contract, if property is lost while Brinks has physical possession, Brinks pays up to the declared value. Its responsibility starts when it picks up the shipment and ends when it delivers. 

D’Amati LLC, the defendant, asked the court to rule without a trial that the contract was illegal – arguing it was really an insurance policy sold without a license. 

The fortuitous event test 

Here is where it gets interesting for anyone in insurance. 

Under New York Insurance Law section 1101, an insurance contract requires that the payout depend on a “fortuitous event” – something substantially beyond either party’s control. Think fire, theft, a storm. The kind of risk insurers price every day. 

But when a carrier holds your goods and promises to pay if they disappear on its watch, the loss is not beyond the carrier’s control. It is the carrier’s core responsibility. That distinction made the difference. 

The court cited a 1994 opinion from the Department of Insurance that reached the same conclusion about UPS: a shipper that controls a package throughout delivery is not insuring against a fortuitous event. That opinion, the court noted, is entitled to deference. 

Call it what you want 

D’Amati also pointed to the fact that Brinks’ own executives had referred to the contract as one for insurance. The court was unmoved. What the contract says on the page is what counts – not what anyone called it, the court held, applying New York’s “four corners” rule. 

The court also tossed an expert affidavit submitted by the defense that offered an opinion on the central legal question – whether the contract was insurance. Expert opinion on the ultimate legal issue, the court held, is not permitted. 

For underwriters, brokers, and coverage counsel handling high-value cargo accounts, the decision offers a fresh, citable distinction between a carrier’s contractual liability for goods in its possession and an actual insurance product. 

The decision was entered on November 19, 2026 and is subject to revision before publication in the Official Reports. 



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *