What makes a tax good or bad? Most people think taxes are bad, but they need the state to function, so they put up with them.
But taxes are not equal – there are major and minor ones; there are efficient and inefficient ones; there are Pigouvian ones (taxing something “bad” such as drinking and smoking for the supposed good of society) and there are ones justified on principles of “fairness” – like higher tax rates for the rich or inheritance tax.
There are a few indefensible ones (penal stamp duty rates on homes being a stand-out example). But there is one tax – capital gains tax – which has an almost unique distinction. Despite its name, it often taxes a person’s economic loss.
How so?
Today, capital gains tax is triggered by an asset owner deciding to sell an asset that they own. In that sense, it is a voluntary tax, since selling or not selling an asset is usually (but not always) a choice. Some assets are exempt from capital gains tax, for example an individual’s principal residence, and UK government gilts.
But most assets fall into the capital gains tax net. Typically these are second and subsequent homes, commercial property, shares (equities), and most financial instruments. There are some more minor specific exemptions, mainly for government schemes such as the Enterprise Investment Scheme, and a small annual tax-free allowance.
Let me give you a worked example to illustrate my immorality case.
The second home
It’s the year 2000, and a UK resident buys a second home in the UK. It costs £750,000 to buy, and it isn’t subsequently let, but kept for the owner’s and their family’s use.
In mid-2025, the owner decides to sell and accepts an offer of £850,000. For simplicity I’ll ignore the charges and costs (including stamp duty) in the calculation. In the 2025-26 tax return, the owner will report a gain of £100,000, and (assuming their other income is more than £50,270 a year) will be required to pay 24pc of the gain (£24,000) to HMRC.
But holding a property for 25 years, and it only going up by £100,000, is a noticeably poor performance. There could be multiple reasons for that, but HMRC isn’t interested. You made a “gain” of £100,000, hence your capital gains tax liability.
But investment in property (or shares) is by its nature a long-term activity. The whole point of these types of investments is that they are capable of keeping up with, or beating, inflation. And when we try to establish whether a particular long-term investment is a good one, we always look to see whether it beat inflation or not.
If it didn’t, then the investor can buy less with their money with the sale proceeds of their investment than they could buy with the money they invested. On any measure, that loss of purchasing power means that the investment wasn’t a success. Let’s call not beating inflation a “loss”. That seems reasonable.
So how much would a home bought in 2000 for £750,000 have to be worth to match inflation if it were sold in 2025?
The answer depends on which inflation index we use. If we use the Retail Prices Index (RPI), used for student loan interest and for index-linked gilt uprating, then it would have to be sold for £1.77m to break even.
That’s cumulative inflation of 136pc over 25 years. If the inflation index used is the Consumer Prices Index (CPI), used for the Bank of England’s 2pc target, then it would have to be worth £1.43m to break even. So on any reasonable assessment, this property investment has been pretty much a disaster.
It has lost (in today’s money) either £923,000 or 52pc of your investment if indexed by RPI, or £579,000 or 41pc if indexed by CPI.
Our investor in this case should therefore really have been able to claim a substantial tax loss, not pay £24,000 in tax. That loss could be used to offset genuine gains elsewhere, or rolled forward to shelter genuine future gains. As it is, our investor is being charged £24,000 by HMRC on a non-existent real gain on a frankly disastrous investment.
This is not a marginal or esoteric point – it’s fundamental to long-term investment in an era of inflation.
The business owner
And for business owners (I happen to be one of these), an investment in a business, which could be held in shares in a limited company for many decades (in my case I still hold shares I bought in 1983), will be taxed on a basis so at odds with economic reality that it really does break the rules of fairness.
In short, the failure to index capital gains tax has turned it from a reasonable charge on entrepreneurial or investment risk-takers, to an immoral tax.
Was this always the case? No.
Capital gains tax is a relatively new tax in the UK, introduced in 1965. Before that, capital gains were not taxed. In 1982, following a period of unprecedented inflation in the 1970s, the then chancellor announced that from that date future asset purchase costs would be uprated by RPI inflation in calculating the amount of capital gains tax payable.
This concession was further extended in 1988 to revalue all assets bought before 1982 to their 1982 values for capital gains tax purposes to avoid penalising long-term asset-owners with large capital gains tax bills arising from 1970s inflation.
In 1988, Nigel Lawson also equalised capital gains tax and income tax rates (changing the capital gains tax rate from 30pc to either 25pc or 40pc depending on the scale of income and gain). The resulting calculations were often complex, but did at least create a sound moral and economic basis on which tax was charged.
All this came to an end in 1998, when Gordon Brown abolished indexation, including for assets purchased in earlier years and still held. In the years since, the rates of capital gains tax have varied widely, from 40pc (matching income tax) to 10pc for long-held shares enjoying taper relief.
Currently the rates are 18pc for an individual with combined income and capital gains less than £50,270, and 24pc for higher-rate taxpayers. These are towards the lower end of international comparator rates, particularly for developed economies. However, some countries (for example, somewhat surprisingly, New Zealand) do not have capital gains tax.
Capital gains tax has been a rising tide of revenue for the Government. In the past decade (2015-16 to 2025-26), HMRC data show that capital gains tax receipts have risen sharply from £7bn in 2015-16 to £24.3bn in 2025-26.
The 2025-26 figure is noticeably higher than the previous few years, where revenue from capital gains tax was averaging around £14bn. There was a great deal of speculation around the 2025 Budget that capital gains tax rates might be equalised with income tax rates, so it’s likely that some asset sales were brought forward.
This implies that receipts could fall back somewhat in the next few years. But inflation, quiescent in the 2010-20 period, has been much higher in the past six years. So higher inflation will feed through to higher capital gains tax receipts, despite much of the gains charged being illusory.
It is impossible to calculate – without detailed recourse to HMRC records – how much of the current £24bn-a-year capital gains tax revenue is because of inflation, but my guess is that it’s a significant proportion.
To raise billions of pounds from investors who have in fact lost money isn’t fair. It may be low down the list of complaints about the Government’s fiscal behaviour, but I believe that our leaders should try to uphold some basic moral principles. Their failure in their application of this tax breaches those principles.
